clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Evaluating the Chiefs’ options at punter

After Dustin Colquitt’s release, who are the candidates to fill the Chiefs open punter position?

LSU v Florida Photo by Sam Greenwood/Getty Images

Late on Monday night, we hit the end of an era. in a cost-saving move, the Kansas City Chiefs released punter Dustin Colquitt, saving $2 million in salary-cap space for the coming season and providing $1.3 million in immediate cap relief.

So where will Chiefs will go from here?

Colquitt has been a stable presence for the last 15 seasons, making punter a set-it-and-forget-it position. The Chiefs have two punters currently on the roster: rookie undrafted free agent Tommy Townsend from Florida and second-year punter Tyler Newsome, who spent the 2019 preseason with the Los Angeles Chargers.

And they both have awesome hair!

Let’s take a look at both players — and how they stack up in a Hair vs. Hair showdown to become the Chiefs’ next punter.

Tommy Townsend

Florida v Vanderbilt Photo by Frederick Breedon/Getty Images

The Chiefs are reported to have given Townsend $82,500 guaranteed on his UDFA contract. That’s a sizable commitment for a rookie punter. Townsend has a good leg, averaging 44 yards per punt in 2019 — including a 71-yard bomb against the Missouri Tigers. He dropped a solid 47.6% of his punts inside the 20-yard line. As a reference, Colquitt dropped 43.8% of his punts inside the 20 during 2019.

In 2019, Townsend also helped the Florida Gators have the third-best punt return average in the FBS: just 1.29 yards per return. His directional kicking and kick placement were solid, allowing his coverage team to get downfield and make the play.

Where Townsend may have a leg up on the competition is his comfort level as a holder for field goals and extra points — something for which Colquitt was responsible during his entire Kansas City tenure. Townsend held that task full-time at Florida.

Tyler Newsome

NCAA Football: Vanderbilt at Notre Dame Matt Cashore-USA TODAY Sports

Of the two, Newsome is the big bomber, showcasing a cannon of a leg during his time at Notre Dame. He has fantastic hang time, and he averaged 44.7 yards per punt in his senior year — including a game against Vanderbilt in which three of his punts traveled over 60 yards. He’s a bigger punter, too — putting up 30 bench reps in the 2018 NFL Combine.

Newsome’s performance inside the 20 isn’t quite as good as Townsend’s, dropping just 35.8% percent of his punts there. He also had nine touchbacks. While his hang time is excellent, Newsome will too often out-kick his coverage, allowing far too many returns. In last year’s preseason with the Chargers, 6 of his 7 punts were returned for an average of 7.7 yards.

The bottom line

Super Bowl LIV - San Francisco 49ers v Kansas City Chiefs Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images

Since he displays better placement and directional kicking ability, I think the job is Townsend’s to lose. Newsome’s distance is certainly tantalizing, but Chiefs special teams coach Dave Toub asks his punters to place the ball a lot more consistently than Newsome has in the past. Adding Townsend’s day-one ability to be a holder for Harrison Butker only makes the decision easier for the Chiefs.

I’m giving Townsend the nod to replace a Chiefs legend in 2020.


Who wins the job?

This poll is closed

  • 90%
    Tommy Townsend
    (2392 votes)
  • 9%
    Tyler Newsome
    (246 votes)
2638 votes total Vote Now

NEW: Join Arrowhead Pride Premier

If you love Arrowhead Pride, you won’t want to miss Pete Sweeney in your inbox each week as he delivers deep analysis and insights on the Chiefs' path to the Super Bowl.