clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

The downfall of a GM: 4 years of Scott Pioli approval ratings

Clark Hunt fired GM Scott Pioli on Friday, almost four years to the day after he hired him. Arrowhead Pride's monthly approval ratings over the last four years help tell the tale of the downfall of Scott Pioli as the GM of the Chiefs.

John Rieger-USA TODAY Sports

I knew these monthly approval ratings would come in handy one day.

What you see below is a graph of our monthly approval ratings for the now former GM of the Kansas City Chiefs, Scott Pioli.

More: Complete Chiefs GM search coverage | Packers exec the leading candidate

We ran an approval poll in Pioli's first month on the job through the last month. This graph is the result and ... well, it kinda tells the whole story, doesn't it?

(Click to view it larger ... credit goes to Clay Wendler for creating the graph)


Several things jump out at me.

1. Pioli's status was never really questioned in the first two years.

Even during that miserable 4-12 2009 season, his numbers were staying (mostly) above 70 percent. The 2010 season was a playoff season, the draft picks looked good ... the numbers were through the roof.

In fact, think about this craziness: In December 2010, 1,850 people voted in the poll.

NINE voters did not approve. Not percent. Voters.

That's just ... wow.

Then again, that's about the time Jamaal Charles signed his extension. So, not all bad.

2. Expectations caught up to him

There were two big declines -- the one before the 2011 season and the one before the 2012 season.

The reason? Expectations.

Coming off the 2010 season, we all thought the Chiefs were going to be good in 2011. Nope. They weren't. Even then, heading into the 2012 season, plenty of people had the Chiefs and Broncos battling it out for the AFC West title. Nah. How about two wins instead?

The fan reaction is one thing when everyone expects you to be bad. But when you put high expectations into the fold ... you better be good.

3. The last three months of the Pioli era truly were the worst. It was time.

What stands out to you?


The complete history of Scott Pioli approval ratings (click the link for full results):

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Arrowhead Pride Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of all your Kansas City Chiefs news from Arrowhead Pride