Admittedly, I'm not knowledgeable in the least bit about NWMS football (but I appear on a radio show in Maryville! That counts, right?)
Per NFL Draft Scout, there are two prospects that are likely to receive interest in the NFL -- SS Myles Burnsides and RB LaRon Council.
NWMS is D-II but Burnsides appears to have had a heck of a career. He's a two-time All American (for the non-D-I schools) and a two-time Academic All American as well as the 2008 national defensive player of the year. He holds the school record for tackles by a defensive back and is 8th overall. His 16 career interceptions are third most in NWMS history.
Council was the 8th leading rusher in the country with 1,202 yards and a 5.7 yards per carry average. He was also selected to the 2009 All-MIAA team.
Don't discount these small schools. The team that NWMS beat in the National Championship this year? Grand Valley State, home of Chiefs two-year starting corner Brandon Carr.
You Bearcats out there let us know who we're missing.