Rick Gosselin of the Dallas Morning News compiled quite a bit of data based on the 2008-2009 season to measure the best and the worst specials teams units in the NFL.
He ranked teams based on 22 special teams statistical categories including punt/kickoff returns, average starting position, field goal accuracy, net punts and so on (click the link above for the full list). Just about any special teams statistic is included in his ranking.
Click through to see how the Chiefs fared (not well) in comparison to the rest of the league.
- Buffalo Bills
- Tennessee Titans
- Cleveland Browns
- New York Giants
- Oakland Raiders
- San Francisco 49ers
- New England Patriots
- Chicago Bears
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers
- Atlanta Falcons
- San Diego Chargers
- Carolina Panthers
- Philadelphia Eagles
- New York Jets
- Seattle Seahawks
- Jacksonville Jaguars
- St. Louis Rams
- New Orleans Saints
- Detroit Lions
- Pittsburgh Steelers
- Houston Texans
- Baltimore Ravens
- Washington Redskins
- Cincinnati Bengals
- Minnesota Vikings
- Green Bay Packers
- Dallas Cowboys
- Arizona Cardinals
- Kansas City Chiefs
- Miami Dolphins
- Denver Broncos
- Indianapolis Colts
*A quick side note before we get to the Chiefs and why they're so low on the list. I bolded the playoff teams because I was somewhat surprised that special teams as a whole isn't any kind of indicator as to how successful a team will be. 6 playoff teams ranked in the top 13 of league and 6 ranked in the bottom 20. Maybe there's nothing to it but I thought it was interesting to note.
The Chiefs were the fourth worst team in the NFL. Much of that can be contributed to the return game that featured four players at one point or another throughout the season (Dantrell Savage, Kevin Robinson, Jamaal Charles and B.J. Sams).
Since B.J. Sams is not on the team anymore (!!!), let's take a look at our two primary punt returners last season, Dantrell Savage and Kevin Robinson, both of whom appeared in 8 games.
| Player | Returns | Yards | Long | Average |
| Dantrell Savage | 8 | 17 | 11 | 2.1 |
| Kevin Robinson | 11 | 94 | 32 | 8.5 |
League average: 9.3 yards per return
Not too impressive. The lack of actual returns makes me suspicious of the coverage team. With punt returns, it's definitely a joint effort. The return man usually has to make at least one man miss to gain anything of substance. Collaboratively, the coverage team has to give him something after he makes the first guy miss. Judging by these stats, someone wasn't doing their job.
Now to the kick return game. Again, since B.J. Sams is off the team now (!!!), we'll focus on Dantrell Savage, Kevin Robinson and Jamaal Charles.
| Player | Returns | Yards | Long | Average |
| Dantrell Savage | 26 | 633 | 59 | 24.3 |
| Kevin Robinson | 19 | 420 | 36 | 22.1 |
| Jamaal Charles | 15 | 321 | 40 | 21.4 |
League average: 22.8 yards per return
Things don't look so bad here. Kickoff returns don't vary much around the league. Last year Tennessee led the league with 25.4 yards per return while Green Bay was the worst with 20.1 yards per return. 5 yards may not seem like much, but it does make a difference, especially with an offense like the Chiefs that had trouble scoring at times. Not to sound too much like Herm here, but those 5 yards could be the difference between a 40 yard field goal and a 35 yard field goal (which, once you look at the stats below, could actually mean something for the Chiefs).
The Chiefs definitely improved in the kicking game once Connor Barth replaced Nick Novak. Though Barth's future with the Chiefs is still a question mark, his performance clearly beat Novak's.
| Player | 20-29 | 30-39 | 40-49 | 50+ |
| Connor Barth | 6/6 | 3/4 | 1/1 | 0/1 |
| NIck Novak | 3/3 | 1/3 | 2/3 | 0/1 |
League average: 84.5%
Overall, Barth completed 10/12 kicks for an 83.3% success rate. Novak, on the other hand, only completed 60% of his 10 kicks.
I say Barth's future on the team is definitely in question because he's still got plenty of tests to pass. With only 2 attempts beyond 40 yards, consider him an incomplete at this point. Besides, the difference between the highest rated kicker in the league and the lowest rated kicker isn't much so the turnover rate is high.
Our punter, Dustin Colquitt, is the only real positive to come out of this statistical ranking. He netted 44.4 yards on his punts in 2008. I won't spend much time discussing him because he's not going anywhere and I can assume we're all pretty happy with his performance.
The Chiefs finished last in the NFL in two of Gosselin's categories that helped comprise this list:
- Opponent's starting point - 31.9 yard line. Compare this with Jacksonville who help opponents just 24.5 yards from the end zone. The Chiefs defense, on average, spotted the other team 7.4 yards before they even took the field in comparison to the Jaguars. It's the little things on special teams that can go a long way to helping an already battered unit like the Chiefs defense.
- Field Goal - 16. Compare this to the New England Patriots and New York Giants, both of whom ended the season with 36 3 pointers. Is it the punt/kick return starting position? Is it the running game? Is it the kicking game? For a coach that admittedly enjoyed a defensive game comprised of field goals, Herm sure was bad at fielding a squad who could kick the ball through the uprights with some regularity.
Who is responsible for the Chiefs special teams woes?
Mike Priefer. Luckily for us Priefer has been plucked (plucked?) by the Denver Broncos to man their special teams unit. Click here to see what AP had to say about Priefer when Styg50 from Mile High Report asked about him.
Priefer came on board in 2006 with Herm Edwards so it's no surprise that he's gone when that and the Chiefs special teams ranking is taken into account.
With Priefer gone, the Chiefs can start fresh. Kevin Robinson appears to be promising in the kicking game, which he should be considering he was drafted as a return specialist (even if it was in the 6th round). Connor Barth is a big maybe at this point in the kicking game.
I'll say Dustin Colquitt is the only player who is guaranteed to make it through the regime change unscathed. Barth and Robinson were primarily special teams players (unlike Savage and Charles who I won't count here) and they've got no guarantees they'll be around next season considering they helped comprise a special teams unit that ranked 29th in the NFL.
An example of "getting it right"
Keeping with Scott Pioli and Todd Haley's theme of "Getting it Right", I wanted to include a quick example of one team that has gotten it right when it comes to special teams. Bobby April is assisted by DeMontie Cross in the Bills special teams department.
The Buffalo Bills have topped Gosselin's special teams rankings 3 of the last 5 years. Their kicker (Rian Lindell) and punter (Brian Moorman) are two of the best in the league.
Where the Bills have shined as well is the return game. Rookie Leodis McKelvin had an excellent season scoring one touchdown and averaging 28.2 yards per return. The punt return game is equally as impressive with Roscoe Parrish adding another touchdown on 15.3 yards per return. Both of those numbers are near the top of the NFL.
How long has special teams been a problem?
The Chiefs special teams unit has gone from one of the best (2003) to one of the worst (2008) in just 6 short years. Let's take a look at how the Chiefs have fared in comparison to the rest of the league in 3 major special teams categories over the last 6 years.
| Year | Punt Return Average | Kick Return Average | Field Goals Made |
| 2003 | 1st | 1st | 15th |
| 2004 | 9th | 3rd | 27th |
| 2005 | 24th | 10th | 14th |
| 2006 | 23rd | 24th | 20th |
| 2007 | 25th | 30th | 20th |
| 2008 | 29th | 27th | 31st |
***
I'm not going to lie to you all and act like I know much about special teams coaches around the NFL. There are excellent special teams coaches out there however. John Harbaugh was the special teams coach in Philadelphia for 9 years before stepping into the secondary coach role for 1 year before getting tabbed as the Baltimore Ravens newest head coach.
So, while special teams coaches won't get much publicity or credit, they do have influence and many of them aren't just fillers. They can be good coaches who can add a lot to a team.
The special teams coach is a position that will be filled by Todd Haley hopefully within the next week to two weeks.