clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Placing a Value on the Chiefs 3rd Pick in the NFL Draft



Primetime did the leg work on this post and I added the intro. -Chris

Unfortunately (or fortunately depending on your view), the Kansas City Chiefs find themselves in familiar territory in the 2009 draft with another top five pick.

Every year, fans of teams with high picks point out the obvious move- trade that high draft pick for more draft picks and move down to still get the player we want!

Alas, if it was that easy.

As guaranteed salaries have increased, trades in the top five slots of the draft have been the rarest, with swaps increasingly common only once you get outside of the top ten.

As far as placing out a value on the Chiefs #3 pick, you can go by the Draft Pick Value Chart a straight number comparison or you can take a look after the jump at the last ten years and see what teams have traded for their top ten draft picks. Sure, the Draft Pick Value Chart may say a pick is worth XYZ other picks, but it only takes one stupid team (cough Lions cough) to gamble on a player who they simply must have. 

Teams panic. Players get overhyped. It's the draft baby!

Jump over to see the last ten years of top ten draft pick trades.


Panthers get: Sean Gilbert (non-exclusive franchise player)

Redskins get: 1999 1st round pick (#5) and 2000 1st round pick (#12)

If Matt Cassel is franchised at the non-exclusive tender, then the Chiefs would have to give up their 3rd overall pick in 2009 AND their 2010 1st round draft pick.  Absent a trade, this is the price a team would have to pay for Cassel's services.


Redskins get: 1st (#12), 3rd (#71), 4th (#107), 5th (#144), 6th (#179) and 7th (#218) in 1999 and 1st (#2) and 3rd (#64) in 2000.

Saints get: 1st (#5 - Ricky Williams)

This isn't exactly the best example of a draft day trade.  The Redskins absolutely fleeced the Saints.  A lot of folks would call this the worst trade in NFL history. This has nothing on the Herschel Walker trade (H/T UC).  Good call, Mike Ditka.


49ers get: Two 1sts (#12 and #24)

Redskins get: 1st (#3 - Chris Samuels)

Perfect.  This is exactly what I want the Chiefs to do.  Only problem is that the top few picks in the draft have been becoming less and less valuable due to the financial demands that come with it.  But I would be ecstatic if Pioli and Co. could strike a deal like this.


Broncos get: 1st (#15) and 2nd (#45)

Ravens get: 1st (#10)


Chargers get: 1st (#5) and 3rd (#67)i and 2002 2nd (#48)

Falcons get: 1st (#1 - Michael Vick)

With more than a few teams possibly clamoring for Michael Crabtree's services, wouldn't it be nice if the Chiefs could move back 3-5 spots, still get the guy they want at a cheaper rate AND pick up an extra 2nd rounder?


49ers get: 1st (#7) and 6th (#191)

Seahawks get: 1st (#9), 3rd (#82) and 7th (#222) round picks


Chiefs get: 1st (#6)

Cowboys get: 1st (#8) and 3rd (#75) and 2003 6th (#187)

Yikes! A 3rd and a 6th to drop back 2 spots?  At least the Chiefs shored up the defensive tackle position with this pick.

.....Wait a minute....


Jets get: Two 1sts (#13 and #22) and 4th (#116)

Bears get: 1st (#4)

Another good example of what the Chiefs could expect in a trade where they move out of the top 10. 


Saints get: 1st (#6), 2nd (#37) and 4th (#102)

Cardinals get: Two 1sts (#17 and #18) and 2nd (#54)

6th overall turns into two picks in the teens.  Again, for a team like the Chiefs with more than a few holes to fill, this is the best case scenario.


Browns get: 1st (#6)

Lions get: 1st (#7) and 2nd (#37)

Hope Kellen Winslow, Jr. has been worth it, Cleveland.


Vikings get: 1st (#7), 7th (#219) and Napoleon Harris

Raiders get: Randy Moss


No top 10 draft picks traded


Falcons get: 1st (#8) and 2nd (#39) and 2008 2nd (#48)

Texans get: 1st (#10) and Matt Schaub

A bit scary to think that Schaub had started 2 games prior to this trade.  Cassel excelled in 15 starts.  Hmm...


Patriots get: 1st (#7)

49ers get: 2007 1st (#28) and 4th (#110)*

*Note: 49ers made this trade in 2007 but it wasn't complete until 2008.  The 1st rounder they traded was conditional and happened to be very high in 2008 after a disappointing 2007 campaign.


Patriots get: 1st (#10) and 3rd (#78)

Saints get: 1st (#7) and 5th (#164)


Take a look at the draft order and let us know if you see any potential trades.

Arrowhead Pride Premiere

Sign up now for a 7-day free trial of Arrowhead Pride Premier, with exclusive updates from Pete Sweeney on the ground at Arrowhead, instant reactions after each game, and in-depth Chiefs analysis from film expert Jon Ledyard.