clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Open Thread: Could Herm Have Succeeded Under Pioli?

New, comments

Gal_jets_1_medium

Since we're simply waiting until after the Super Bowl for head coaching news, I wanted to throw out a hypothetical question for a nice, relaxing Friday discussion.

The question is:

Could Herm Edwards consistently win football games with Scott Pioli calling the shots at GM?

Imagine that we didn't have Herm Edwards as our previous coach and that Pioli brings Edwards in right now as the Kansas City Chiefs new head coach. No 2-14 albatross around his neck...Herm would be able to continue the rebuilding right away...

Does Herm succeed two, three, however many years down the line with Pioli calling many of the shots? Or is Herm so broken as a head coach that nobody can help him?