If you could pick one, who would you take? In all honesty I'd rank them. Charles 1. McCoy 2. Peterson 3. With how the game is played having a RB who can catch is getting just as important as being a grinder. Would any of you guys take Peterson or McCoy over Charles? I'd say how the game was played 4-5 years ago I'd go for Peterson but with the pass happy league JC and McCoy seem to have more value.