I have been one of the strongest critics of Geno Smith and one that has pushed hard for other options at QB next season. But, after reading many of the posts and threads about QBs available, and studying Smith in depth, I have changed my mind. I believe that the rough stretch he had during the 2012 season was an outlier, not the norm. I don't think there are better options this year, IMO, and this may be our only shot at a #1 pick (hopefully). Obviously, I trust Reid & Co. to go through the evaluation process, but if we had to make the pick today, it would have to be GS.
I know this is one of many, many posts about Geno, but opinions change all of the time, so what are your current thoughts on Smith?
What do you think about Geno?
Drafting him would be a huge mistake, he's awful. (6 votes)
Not a huge fan, but there are worse options out there. (17 votes)
He's still got a lot to prove. I'm neutral. (23 votes)
He's pretty good, not great. I'd be happy with the pick. (69 votes)
Not drafting him would be a huge mistake, he's the best. (81 votes)
196 total votes