I won the super bowl in years 1 and 2 with the Chiefs in madden 12 in a couple of different modes. When I won in Year 1, the postgame was really satisfying, down to Gus Johnson discussing Haley, Pioli, and the Chiefs' history. For all the rest of the flaws of the game, that was a really cool moment and felt like our Chiefs had really just won it all. Year 2's win, while still a decent moment, was really generic in comparison, and I expect that any won past that will be too.