Chiefs vs Raiders II: Breaking Down The O-Line Tape

Week #17
The Kansas City Chiefs were defeated by the Oakland Raiders this past Sunday. And if the Chiefs want to go further than the first round of the playoffs they will have to perform better than they did against the Raiders.
It's no surprise that the Chiefs had a hard time with the Raiders. I predicted such a game just three weeks ago in my article (here). The problem is that the Ravens are just the same kind of team that the Chiefs have been having problems with all year. KC better get something figured out...and soon.
Let's take a look at those O-line grades from the Raider game.

| 10 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 100 |
|
| Percent Scale | ||||||||||
- Please refer to the Chiefs Preseason: Breaking Down The O-Line Tape - Primer at the bottom of this article for any inquiries into the method used to grade the lineman.
| Team Run Blocking |
Power Blocking |
Power Blocking Score |
2nd Level Blocks |
||||
| Did the lineman get the job done or not? These grades are good for understanding value for a team and not necessarily for comparing across teams. A game in the mid 80s to 90% is a decent score. |
How often did the offensive lineman dominate the block or how often did he get dominated? These scores are good for comparing across teams and finding the most dominant lineman in the league. |
Anything over zero is a good score. The more over zero the more the lineman dominated the defender. Each lineman is scored a minus for being dominated, a zero for a draw, or a plus for dominating the defender. |
The number of success over failures for the lineman when blocking linebackers and safeties on the second level. The lineman must be athletic to accomplish a high second level score. |
Run Blocking Grades
| Percent |
10 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 100 | Power |
2/Level |
Pull |
||
| Grade | |
Blocking |
Blocking |
Blocks |
|||||||||||
| Albert | 66% |
-8 |
+2 |
+1 |
|||||||||||
| Waters | 86% |
-6 |
+4 |
-2 |
|||||||||||
| Wiegmann | 83% |
-9 | +4 |
+0 |
|||||||||||
| Lilja | 83% |
-3 | +2 |
+4 |
|||||||||||
| Richardson | 86% |
-1 | +2 |
+0 |
|||||||||||
| O'Callaghan | -- |
N/A |
--- | --- |
--- |
||||||||||
| Asamoah | -- |
N/A |
--- | --- |
--- |
||||||||||
| Pope | 92% |
-2 | +1 |
+0 |
|||||||||||
| Moeaki | 69% |
-3 | +1 |
+0 |
|||||||||||
Run & Pass Blocking Notes:
- If you haven't noticed, I have started to implement some of the upgraded analysis I will be providing next year. I still have the team blocking grades but now I have provided the precise percent score, a power blocking grade, and a different way of representing the second level blocks and pulling that the lineman have done. I would appreciate any feedback.
- The line didn't have a horrible (being relative here) day run blocking as a whole. It still isn't good when all the lineman manage low 80s...but the Raiders were aggressive and stacking the box.
- Albert had a horrible day run blocking. Not only is his team grade horrifyingly low (66%) but his power blocking grade was low. At a (-8) that means Albert was dominated eight more times during the game by the defender compared to how often he dominated his defender in the run game...which wasn't very much.
- As a whole, the Chief's power blocking scores were low. No surprise. The eye test could tell you the Chiefs were not dominating the Raiders.
- With 8:03 in the 3rd quarter, Brian Waters gets a burst of energy and has a nice combo block and then to a linebacker to help Charles into the end zone. I've noticed that Waters' play has become elevated this season when the Chiefs get close to the goal line. Nice to see he still has some left in the tank.
- The Chiefs have had problems with physical teams that can stack the box and have one good cover corner. That is what they are going to see against the Baltimore Ravens.
| Team Pass Blocking |
Passing Power Blocking |
Pressures | Combo Help |
||||
| Did the lineman get the job done or not? These grades are good for understanding value for a team and not necessarily for comparing across teams. A game in the 90% is a good score for pass blocking. |
How often did the offensive lineman dominate the block or how often did he get dominated? Each lineman is scored a minus for being dominated, a zero for a draw, or a plus for dominating the block. | How often did the offensive lineman give up pressure on the quarterback? Every once and a while a lineman can do his job but give up pressure on the QB. This stat will help glean more info from the line grades. |
How often did the offensive coordinator provide help for a tough defender or a struggling lineman. Yea, two lineman ended up with the same grade...but how much help did either of them get? |
Pass Blocking Grades
| Percent |
10 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 100 | Power |
Pressures |
Sacks |
Combo |
||
| Grade | |
Blocking |
Allowed |
Allowed |
Help |
|||||||||||
| Albert | 81% |
-11 |
10 |
2 |
+5 |
|||||||||||
| Waters | 93% |
-3 |
1 |
--- |
+11 |
|||||||||||
| Wiegmann | 93% |
-5 | 2 |
--- |
+11 |
|||||||||||
| Lilja | 86% |
-16 | 5 |
--- |
+8 |
|||||||||||
| Richardson | 86% |
-6 | 4 |
3 |
+14 |
|||||||||||
| O'Callaghan | --- |
N/A |
--- | --- |
--- |
--- |
||||||||||
| Asamoah | --- |
N/A |
--- | --- |
--- |
--- |
||||||||||
| Pope | 92% |
-1 | --- |
--- |
+6 |
|||||||||||
| Moeaki | 88% |
-3 | 2 |
--- |
+4 |
|||||||||||
Run & Pass Blocking Notes:
- The pass blocking against the Raiders was bad: Lineman, tight ends, backs...they all had an off day.
- Lineman try and get a team pass blocking grade of 90%: Only Waters and Wiegmann got up that high.
- By the looks of the team grades you might think that some of the Chief's lineman didn't do that bad. That is why I have started providing the other stats. For example, Albert had a pass blocking grade of 81%...not good but not really bad. But when looking at the other numbers we see that his power blocking score was at a (-11). That mean that his defender dominated him 11 more times than he dominated the defender (that's poor). We can also see that Albert allowed 10 pressures, 2 sacks, and was helped by another lineman or back during pass protection 5 times. After looking at all those numbers we can see really how bad Brandon did.
- Richardson had a team line grade of 86%...but look how many times he had a help block. He was helped 14 times so when he wasn't being helped he must have did very poor. A lineman usually gets a job done when he has help with his defender so that inflates the team line grade.
- At 3:47 in the 3Q Jake O'Connell gives up a sack.
- Late in the second half the line gives up pressure and sacks three plays in a row. Hard to watch.
- Lilja is a smart, undersized, lineman. That is why his pass protection team grade was 86%. But if you look closer at his power pass blocking score you will see he was handled pretty good by his defender. A dominant pass blocking score of (-16) is really bad.
- At 4:32 in the second quarter Barry Richardson's defender runs down the line of scrimmage to make a sack on the opposite side of the field. Barry was not charged with a sack in my book.
- The running backs give up some pressure and a sack during a slide protection a couple of times.
OTHER SEASON STATS
| Player |
Games Played |
# Penalties | # of Drivens |
# Sacks |
|||||
| Albert | 14 | 5 | 7 | 6 |
|||||
| Waters | 15 | 1 | 24 | 0 |
|||||
| Wiegmann | 15 | 2 | 41 | 2 |
|||||
| Lilja | 14 | 4 | 27 |
1 |
|||||
| O'Callaghan | 4 | 0 | 3 | 1 |
|||||
| Pope | 15 | 5 | 8 | 1 |
|||||
| Richardson |
15 |
7 |
14 |
5 |
|||||
| Asamoah |
2 |
0 |
5 |
0 |

Click On " Bewsaf Past Posts " for more past articles
| *Chiefs Preseason: Breaking Down The O-Line Tape - Primer | *What You Look For in an NFL Offensive Lineman - The Basics |
*It's All About The Match-ups When Asking If The Chiefs Can Win The AFC West |
77 comments
|
7 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Oh sweet Jesus I don't know if I can read this post,
but I will.
by NJ Chiefs Fan on Jan 3, 2011 10:04 AM CST reply actions 1 recs
Had me laughing there NJ!
I had the same exact thought. I can’t do this here at my desk – I’ll save it for lunch.
by stl chiefs fan on Jan 3, 2011 10:35 AM CST up reply actions
Why wait?
Better do it before lunch, otherwise you might throw up.
by Yaggleberry Finn on Jan 3, 2011 11:12 AM CST up reply actions
I like the new format and stats!
One question, I noticed Richardson was struggling and thought I saw O’Call replace him, to my relief and then my horror as he immediately gave up a sack. Did I see that wrong? I think there was penalty or time out right then, so he may have come back out, but I’m not sure. Did he really not see any pass blocking duty?
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. ~ Groucho Marx
It would be an insult to ever consider moving him to RT
And drafting a LT.
The performance by the OL yesterday was horrid.
Albert was worse than awful
Embarrassing. When your rookie year is your best, there is a problem. He’s regressing.
bewsaf - are these grades
better than the SD game. I actually thought they would be worse with the beating Cassel took.
A couple of things inflate the team passing grade
1) the number of times they get combo help in the passing game. Every time they get help that adds another job done to the score which waters down the times when they are left alone to pass block.
2) After the pressure started Cassel didn’t move around as well as he should. Of course he was shell shocked I’m sure. But the job assignment given the lineman is to make sure he doesn’t reach the QB…so some of the times a pressure is given up but the lineman recovered from a mistake and ended up doing his job. That’s why I started adding the Power Blocking grade and the pressures.
3) Many times the Raiders sent more defenders than a lineman could handle so the lineman tried to get a piece of both of them to slow them down. The lineman does his job to buy the QB more time but in the end the team needs hot reads.
anyway that is a couple of them. Also, the Chiefs passes so much and ended up keeping in so many TEs and RBs that the lineman stated diluting their bad performance with some help blocks. But then the TEs and RBs stared getting beat.
Bewsaf@comcast.net
so you're saying what I said yesterday, with only my eye and memory
1) the raiders were blitzing more guys than could be blocked. (That’s on Cassel).
2) Cassel started hanging onto the ball too long, trying to make a play. (That’s on Cassel).
Sure, the line looked horrible, and I’m sure they were dominated a good portion of the time, but Cassel, receivers, Haley and Weis didn’t help things AT ALL. In fact, they made it worse.
It was so bad that it makes me wonder if Haley and Weis weren’t just trying to work on a few things for the playoffs.
That said, I do disagree on the comparisons to the Raiders’ and Ravens’ defense. They may both be physical, but Baltimore does not possess nowhere near the team speed Oakland does. Al has almost always drafted fastest guy at every position, and with coaching it is starting to pay off. Thus, IMO, it wasn’t the physical defense that killed KC’s offense, it was the combination of physical and speed. And fortunately for KC, the Ravens defense is getting a bit older (slower).
Scott Pioli for President in 2012. Experience? If the current President doesn't need it, why does Pioli? Besides, Pioli has the blue collar work ethic with a white collar brain. He has humility. He is tough on security. He supports war on Sundays. And he makes sound, fiscally conservative decisions.
by chief Stevie_k on Jan 3, 2011 10:38 AM CST up reply actions
Yes..I think the poor protection was exacerbated by the lack of receiver options, lack of hot reads, and a shell shocked QB.
Bewsaf@comcast.net
I think it had more to do with some no-calls (roughing the QB) taking him out of his element mentally.
could probably say that all the way around. Seemed like most of the game Oakland was taking cheap shots and got KC mentally and emotionally frustrated.
Scott Pioli for President in 2012. Experience? If the current President doesn't need it, why does Pioli? Besides, Pioli has the blue collar work ethic with a white collar brain. He has humility. He is tough on security. He supports war on Sundays. And he makes sound, fiscally conservative decisions.
by chief Stevie_k on Jan 3, 2011 11:09 AM CST up reply actions
Good point
it seems to me, Cassel is going through the “Bowe and only Bowe” progressions these days. If he chooses McCluster instead of Bowe (on the one where the safety jarred it loose…in triple coverage) he might get a TD.
All that aside, the OL was horrendous. I need to vomit…
Others made things worse?
You mean like going 5-wide at our own goalline the play after nearly giving up a safety? I’m still scratching my head on that one.
Your eyes tell you more than any statistics can.
This whole disaster could have been offset had Weis adjusted.
The quick throws, short QB drops were working better. But no. Weis stuck with the regular five step drop much of the time knowing full well the offensive line was struggling. I honestly don’t know if KC will miss him very much. Great coach, but I think his ego kind of gets in the way.
I eat nails for breakfast, tacks for snacks, and I sh*t nickel.
by SupremeChief on Jan 3, 2011 10:24 AM CST reply actions 1 recs
I agree. With all the time the Raiders spent in our backfield
some screens and draws would have been a nice adjustment.
Joe
I think Charlie's head is in Florida.
Chiefs will.
10 + wins in 2010. Chiefs SHOCK the NFL!!! Mark it down.
Where was that stellar Cassel leadership everyone talks about?
Weis isn’t on the field. He can’t audible.
We’ll miss Weis next year when we will be lucky to go 8-8 and sitting home watching the playoffs.
Cassel's "leadership" was running for it's freakin' life...just like the rest of him.
And I don’t think we’ll miss Weis one bit. He’s called some decent games, some average games, and some gawd awful games. We’ll be fine without him…and possibly better off, I think.
Chiefs will.
10 + wins in 2010. Chiefs SHOCK the NFL!!! Mark it down.
REALLY
Blaming this on Cassel, UPS, or HIV is that you.
Not really blaming this on Cassel
This is just payback for all the idiots that blamed the same type of game with SD on Croyle and said how much better it would have been if Cassel was playing. Point is when the line plays that god awful, it doesn’t matter who is under center.
I agree.
It also seems that Cassel had a poor day very early; his accuracy was not there, even pathetic. That’s not been Cassel the last half of the season. If he was having a bad day, I’m glad it was week 17 and not the playoffs. Here’s to a rebound. I’m a Cassel backer, btw.
It's really hard to be a decent QB when you constantly have a defender in your grill.
Yes, there were times where Cassel had just enough time to get the ball off but held onto it too long. However, there were defenders in the backfield right off the snap in most instances. That’s where Weis should have called for slants and short crossing routes to minimize the damage.
I eat nails for breakfast, tacks for snacks, and I sh*t nickel.
by SupremeChief on Jan 3, 2011 11:21 AM CST up reply actions
Who in our division is going to be better than us next year?
It sounds like SD is sticking with Norv so expect them to give up the division at the beginning of the season, again. The Raiders will always be the sloppiest rag tag team in the league. And who is left???? Denver?……… Really?. We will win the Division next season barring any major injuries. Weis’s play calling was suspect in every game this year. We are better now for having him but at this point we will be even better next year with fresh talent.
What's with all the play-action
that takes five seconds to develop and we have NO deep options? Why are all the WRs/RBs a maximum of 10-15 yards downfield?
Great presentation Bews...
Another thought for a new graph… perhaps a graph showing amount of “Mayhem” inflicted on our QB. You could symbolize it by the number of Crutch’s placed next to the Offensive Lineman’s Name. We could call them “AFLAC’s”. "The “AFLAC” or “CRUTCH” would be awarded for responsibility for each devestating hit suffered by the QB.
Maybe there is truth to the rumour that the local Red Cross has put out emergency request for "Blood Donations" in anticipation of needs of KC QB's when we play Ravens next Sunday Seriously,….How can we protect QBs when we allow run game to be taken away by opponents stacking the box and at same time allow such pressure when passing?
"You talkin' to me? You TALKIN' to me ?" - Travis Bickle
Bewsaf, is there any chance...
We see Asamoah plugged in for Lilja when we see more physical defenses like this one (and the Ravens)? I know Asamoah is just a rookie but Lilja is TINY!! It’s really quite shocking when you look at him next to our tackles. Do you think that Asamoah could be more effective due to his size alone?
by The Other Patrick Allen on Jan 3, 2011 11:08 AM CST reply actions
I don't think you can pick Lilja out as the problem from yesterday
Any more than anyone else. Albert was the worst, and I’m glad bewsaf’s grade show as much, but they were bad across the board.
I think more than subs, a strategy change is what’s needed, at least for this season. Next season…we may have a couple new starters.
We need a mixture of both types of linemen.
It’s hard to find a strong, physical lineman who is also agile. Our line consists of mostly (if not all) finesse blockers. I hope we draft some decent power blockers this year. Heck, maybe we’ll stumble upon a Shields/Roaf type blocker. Big AND agile.
I eat nails for breakfast, tacks for snacks, and I sh*t nickel.
by SupremeChief on Jan 3, 2011 11:23 AM CST up reply actions
Time to go younger at LG and C, I think.
Those guys have worn down as the season has gone one.
YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!
Oh, I think we need a new C and RT
Casey is probably going to retire anyway, so we’ll need to replace him.
I guess we could put in Asamoah and have he or Waters shift to C…that may be the plan.
We still need to add a tackle and another young interior lineman.
We have our right tackle of the future......... Albert!
"The best way to convince a fool that he is wrong is to let him have his way" Josh Billings
Kansas City Chiefs - 2020 Team of the Decade
I'm not trying to pick on Lilja
But subbing in Asamoah seems to be a logical first step to at least partially remedy our problem of being too small against these physical defenses. On the other hand, swapping out starters at this point could really backfire. You’re right though, it was bad across the board.
by The Other Patrick Allen on Jan 3, 2011 11:39 AM CST up reply actions
I hear you
I just think overall, Lilja may have been our best OL this year. He wouldn’t be the guy I’d be pulling.
Our problem is that the o-line is small....
Look up the stats for our entire offensive line. With exception to Richardson, they are undersized. They are really small in the interior, with Wiegmann, Waters, and Lilja. Teams that have huge defensive lines (like Oakland and San Diego) have ate them alive. It got worse as the game went on too.
That, along with Cassel bailing early out of plays, made yesterday a long day.
Unfortunately, I would assume the Ravens have a soild defensive line (especially with Ngata at nose tackle).
Maybe yesterday's game was all planned by Haley...
To lure the Ravens into a false sense of security?
Chiefs will.
10 + wins in 2010. Chiefs SHOCK the NFL!!! Mark it down.
yeah thats the ticket...................
This was a grand plan to go to NE and beat the crap out of Bilachick and the Patriots.
How painful is this going to be next week?
If the o-line can’t stop Tommy Kelly and Kamerion Wimbley, what the hell are they going to do with Haloti Ngata and Terrell Suggs?
"I don't know if I want to go to New York. They'll have to pay me a lot more money because I like it here in Kansas City." -- Roger Maris
Throw to Jamaal Charles on the flat
That seems to be the logical next point.
by ChiefWarPaint on Jan 3, 2011 11:45 AM CST up reply actions
Et tu Kalo?
Haha. I really don’t think we will. I’m putting my faith in the coaches to come up with an offensive scheme to take advantage of the aggresiveness they are sure to show.
by The Other Patrick Allen on Jan 3, 2011 11:46 AM CST up reply actions
What if Haley...
wants to give a false sense of security to our 2011 opponents, and holds back?
YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!
Ravens only had 27 sacks this year
4th worst in the NFL.
Raiders had 47, 2nd best in the NFL.
They were great against the run, and below average against the pass.
Our OL will be key, but I think the Raiders were a tougher matchup.
And yes, it was a rivalry game.
But Ngata and Suggs often keep that defense in games they shouldn’t be in. If they’re watching the Raiders game, they’ll see that their big, overpowering defenders need to get upfield, rather than try and anchor.
Their corners aren’t very good. Ed Reed is very good, but the rest of that secondary is lacking. passes into the short middle and short flat to TE/RB’s will mostly depend on which Ray Lewis shows up. Still, Suggs against Richardson or Albert will get into the backfield, and with the way Kelly crushed the pocket this week, it’s hard to think Ngata won’t do the same. Won’t leave a lot of places for the quarterback to go.
"I don't know if I want to go to New York. They'll have to pay me a lot more money because I like it here in Kansas City." -- Roger Maris
Really?
And Suggs had like 12 right? That’s really surprising
by The Other Patrick Allen on Jan 3, 2011 11:53 AM CST up reply actions
And Ngata with 5.5.
"I don't know if I want to go to New York. They'll have to pay me a lot more money because I like it here in Kansas City." -- Roger Maris
That's kind of why I'm worried.
It’ll depend on how the offense shifts. If we can get them to sell the farm on the pass rush, a couple of longer runs could be in order, making the defense back off a bit. However, if we come out passing, then try to set up the run, I’m afraid our quarterback might get some happy feet again this week.
"I don't know if I want to go to New York. They'll have to pay me a lot more money because I like it here in Kansas City." -- Roger Maris
Is Ngata constantly demanding double teams as well?
I gotta believe that Casey and Waters/Lilja could contain him with a double team, unless of course you tell me we were double teaming Kelly too…
by The Other Patrick Allen on Jan 3, 2011 12:01 PM CST up reply actions
Ngata is constantly double teamed.
"I don't know if I want to go to New York. They'll have to pay me a lot more money because I like it here in Kansas City." -- Roger Maris
Yup
http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/team/_/stat/defense/sort/sacks
Their D was overrated this year, in a lot of ways living off of past rep.
That said, it’s not like this will be an easy game, or matchup. We have to help with Suggs, whatever side he’s coming from. I think Ngata doesn’t have a sack in the 2nd half of the season…
Maybe overrated.
But 3rd in scoring and 10th in yardage is still pretty good.
YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!
Agreed
Like I said, not an easy matchup at all, just not what they used to be.
I think the defense will have to step up to give us a chance.
And it would be nice if the special teams return units finally got going.
YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!
Ngata has been an animal, still.
Our o-line has got to be lights out to contain Suggs, Ngata, and to get to the second level to block those ILB’s.
"I don't know if I want to go to New York. They'll have to pay me a lot more money because I like it here in Kansas City." -- Roger Maris
They were great against the run, and below average against the pass.
The Ravens, I’m speaking of…
terrific
I think the number one reason I come here anymore is to see your O line breakdowns Bewsaf.
AP and you is about the only place an O line person can really get this much detail and breakdown.
Can’t thank you enough for this.
I love the new breakdowns.
without reading the grades..
i say F’s across the board. ok, now i will go back and read them.
Just like novocaine. give it time; always works..
The greater the fall, the grander the ascention..
Hey, hey, hey!
Who wants to play?
Just like novocaine. give it time; always works..
The greater the fall, the grander the ascention..
I like the new format...
looks like you can glean a little more from this format. Nice work Bewsaf.
I like the new, more detailed format.
Easier to read, more info and very telling. The plus/minus totals tell a lot about which lineman is getting his ass kicked. Sunday, it seemed to be most of them. Great work Bewsaf. Can you suit up for the playoffs?
"The best way to convince a fool that he is wrong is to let him have his way" Josh Billings
Kansas City Chiefs - 2020 Team of the Decade
BEWSAF
I don’t like the tenor of your evaluation. If the Ravens offer the mix of strengths/weaknesses that we struggle with, I’ll start my depression meds now.
When we don’t get the right setup, we get HAMMERED!
How do you think we’re going to do?
CASSEL 2010 LEAGUE MVP...It was in international waters, so they couldn't prosecute him. But I saw it.

by 





























