new position and scheme. Let the man play at least for a full year and then decide in the off season if you are going to keep him. La Canfora (sp) is an ass, never liked him never will. NFLN should have never let Adam go, so much better than Jason. We all knew this was going to be a trial and error year so let’s find “our 53”

Along with T.Jackson, Flowers, and Vrabel, form the nucleus of what will become a very good defense.

There is no way you trade Dorsey. No freakin way. period

To big if a cap hit, plus he might need some time to figure out the new position.

…unless the Raiders offer us the moon (which I’m sure is in the works)

or is this just a case of – Somebody has to make the tackle. I guess another way of putting it would be: If Dorsey wasn’t playing and we had Gilbery (or insert player of your choice) starting in his place…would we be about how good Gilbery is? Are our standards so low at this point that Dorsey looks good?

But we have an offensive minded head coach, and Clancy penedgrast’s defense has never been that good….Im from Phoenix and watched both of them closely the last couple yrs. Arizonas defense played well throughout the playoffs last yr and that was it….They won games because they had a prolific offense that just plain outscored other teams…but they were lucky to make it to the playoffs in the first place..9-7 record…In fact, Clancy was let go because of the defense he called in the last two minutes of the SB that allowed the Steelers to score the go ahead touchdown…So regardless of the players we bring in or who we already have, this defense with Clancy the Clown leading it, will never be great. He might get them to be middle of the row good, but never great. His scheme is not that good…Hell he cant even decide whether to run a 3-4 or a 4-3….Dorsey is a good young player, he has had to change schemes, had two different coaching staffs in two yrs, and has not a lot of talent around him….Its getting better but, we are nowhere near where we should be..I dont see Clancy as the DC next yr…I think he was hired because we got a late start in hiring coaches because we had to wait for Haley to finish their SB run, and then after his hire there was not much to choose from and so we went with Clancy because he was available and Haley was familiar with his system since they were together in AZ…..We are in a rebuilding yr, its not gonna be pretty…Pioli needs a yr to evaluate, get his own players in here and be able to wheel and deal.

Unless we got something totally ridiculous like two 1st rounders I would be against the deal. I think Glenn may end up becoming a phenomenal 3-4 DE and it would be sickening to see him playing for another team, especially since we are in so need of a defensive playmaker.

It is often stated that football is won in the trenches and I think by late next year we will have a truly dominating D-line. Just like a awesome O-line can mask an otherwise mediocre offensive cough Denver an awesome D-line can help mask an otherwise mediocre defense.

Dorsey is going to become an impact player. Just give him a couple of years. It sounds like the “traders” are thinking that it is better to trade a solid performer that is just now coming into his potential, for an unknown rookie that once again needs to go through a one or two year development.

He has only scratched the potential he has, and I believe that he will be rank in the top 10 at his position within the next two to three years. Just about the time we should be running for the SB.