QB comparison for the Bills game

by KC FAN IN CA on Nov 19, 2008 1:45 PM CST Comment 5 comments

I figured I would put the spread sheet I made to some more use. The nice thing is after next week I can have a bigger sample size...

There are two spread sheets one is first five games as a starter the next is five recent starts. I know we are intelligent enought to realize Bones' stats are the same for both...

Remember this is best viewed by pressing the wide button

Games started	W	L	Opponent	Margin of loss	Comp	Att	%	Total yds	Yds per Att avg	TD	INT	Fumb loss	Sack	Yds Loss per sack	QB Rating	Rush Att	Yds per rush
Edwards	1		NYJ 4/12 need I say more?	-3	22	28	78.6%	234	8.36	1	1	0	2	16	98.5	1	-1
		1	DAL 13/3 one and done in the playoffs	1	23	31	74.2%	176	5.68	0	1	0	3	28	74.1	1	6
	1		BAL 5/11 they lost to the dolphins…	-5	11	21	52.4%	153	7.29	0	1	0	2	14	56.2	0	0
	1		NYJ 4/12 see above	-10	14	21	66.7%	130	6.19	0	1	0	1	4	63.6	1	2
	1		WAS 9/7 nfc wild card play off team	-1	22	36	61.1%	257	7.14	0	0	0	0	0	82.8	2	4
Total	4	1		-18	92	137	67.2%	950	6.93	1	4	0	8	62		5	11
Average	W			-3.6	18.4	27.4	66.6%	190	6.93	0.2	0.8	0	1.6	7.75	75.04	1	2.2

Bones		1	Atl 6/4 Playoff contender AFC south	24	14	36	38.9%	128	3.6	1	3	0	2	11	23.8	1	18
		1	NYJ 7/3 AFC East leaders	4	25	36	69.4%	280	7.8	2	0	0	4	30	110.9	4	20
		1	TB 7/3 Playoff contender AFC south	3	14	25	56.0%	164	6.6	1	0	0	1	0	89.4	6	22
		1	SD 4/6 I still expect them to give Denver a run	1	27	41	65.9%	266	6.5	3	0	0	1	3	108.4	2	26
		1	NO 5/5 Best Offense in the league	10	19	38	50.0%	235	6.2	2	1	0	4	29	76.1	3	45
Total		5		42	99	176	56.3%	1073	6.10	9	4	0	12	73		16	131
Average		L		8.4	19.8	35.2	56.0%	214.6	6.14	1.8	0.8	0	2.4	6.1	81.72	3.2	8.19

Some things I noticed

1 TD in 5 games....
Completion percentage over 65%
The margin of loss column is negative???...(see below)
I had to add a column for what are those things called... oh yeah wins (sarcasm)
Not a big runner he was 5/11yds over the five game span

Last Five starts

Games started	W	L	Opponent	Margin of loss	Comp	Att	%	Total yds	Yds per Att avg	TD	INT	Fumb loss	Sack	Yds Loss per sack	QB Rating	Rush Att	Yds per rush
Edwards	1		SD 4/6 see below	-9	25	30	83.3%	261	8.70	1	0	0	0	0	114	4	6
		1	MIA 6/4 2nd in AFC east	9	21	35	60.0%	227	6.49	0	1	1	2	7	67.2	4	17
		1	NYJ 7/3 AFC east leaders	9	24	35	68.6%	289	8.26	1	2	1	5	27	79.3	1	-1
		1	NE 6/4 3rd in AFC east (they are the Pats)	10	13	23	56.5%	120	5.22	1	2	0	2	12	49.2	0	0
		1	CLE 4/6 that was a tough fought game	2	16	26	61.5%	148	5.69	1	3	0	0	0	50.3	3	7
Total	1	4		21	99	149	66.4%	1045	7.01	4	8	2	9	46		12	29
Average		L		4.2	19.8	29.8	66.0%	209	6.87	0.8	1.6	0.4	1.8	5.11	72	2.4	5.8

Bones		1	Atl 6/4 Playoff contender AFC south	24	14	36	38.9%	128	3.6	1	3	0	2	11	23.8	1	18
		1	NYJ 7/3 AFC East leaders	4	25	36	69.4%	280	7.8	2	0	0	4	30	110.9	4	20
		1	TB 7/3 Playoff contender AFC south	3	14	25	56.0%	164	6.6	1	0	0	1	0	89.4	6	22
		1	SD 4/6 I still expect them to give Denver a run	1	27	41	65.9%	266	6.5	3	0	0	1	3	108.4	2	26
		1	NO 5/5 Best Offense in the league	10	19	38	50.0%	235	6.2	2	1	0	4	29	76.1	3	45
Total		5		42	99	176	56.3%	1073	6.10	9	4	0	12	73		16	131
Average		L		8.4	19.8	35.2	56.0%	214.6	6.14	1.8	0.8	0	2.4	6.1	81.72	3.2	8.19

Still holding a 65% completion ratio
Averaging better than 200 yds a game
He is good for two turnovers a game (avg over the last five starts)
QB rating at 72

Hopefully the defense can improve our total YPG average or the BIlls will end there four game skid.

oh yeah Edwards last five starts Edwards first five career starts and Bones (almost forgot to reference the stats, doh!!)

This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Arrowhead Pride's writers or editors. It does reflect the views of this particular fan though, which is as important as the views of Arrowhead Pride writers or editors.

0 recs | Comment 5 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

i think edwards is a better QB

but Thigpen has been playing better lately.

Naming my son Brodie Damon

by troy145 on Nov 20, 2008 5:39 AM CST reply actions 0 recs

possibly

but statistically Edwards best game in the last five was against SD the worst pass defense in league. If you can compare opponenents as a barometer against the Jets Bones played much better than Edwards with one more completion, 8 less yards and most importantly 3 less turnovers.

by KC FAN IN CA on Nov 20, 2008 10:11 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs

its certainly open for debate

both have looked real good and real bad

im not impressed with your performance

by troy145 on Nov 20, 2008 1:00 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs

Yes it is...

but the sample size on bones is too big of a flaw to have an intelligent discussion. and the " Bones is a future HOFer" argument might have some holes in it :)

by KC FAN IN CA on Nov 20, 2008 1:41 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs

I do know that

over the last five games Bones has been hands down the better quarterback and statistically his first five starts were better than edwards less the important win column

by KC FAN IN CA on Nov 20, 2008 1:42 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs